A deductible is the part of a covered claim you pay under the policy's rules. Choosing it changes your balance between recurring premiums and the amount you may need after a loss. There is no single right amount for every driver.
Start with the amount you could pay promptly without missing essential bills. Then ask the insurer for otherwise identical proposals at several deductible levels. This turns a vague decision about affordability into a comparison you can calculate.
Separate collision from comprehensive
Collision generally concerns damage from a collision or overturn, while comprehensive addresses specified non-collision causes such as theft or hail. Read the actual definitions. The two coverages can have different deductibles, and a special glass provision may have its own treatment. Do not assume the largest number on the declarations page applies to every claim.
Measure the premium savings
Write the annual premium beside each proposed deductible. Subtract the higher-deductible premium from the lower-deductible premium to find the annual saving. Then divide the increase in deductible by that saving. This gives a simple number of claim-free years needed for the saving to equal the additional deductible. It does not predict when a loss will occur.
Test the cash-flow problem
A driver who saves $10 per month may still struggle with an extra $500 repair contribution next week. Keep the deductible amount accessible, rather than assuming future savings will cover an immediate event. Include the possibility of more than one incident; deductibles often apply separately to separate losses, subject to the policy.
Check the financing agreement
A lender or lessor may require physical-damage coverage and limit the deductible you may select. Obtain the requirement before choosing the cheapest proposal. If your vehicle's value is falling, compare its realistic value with the deductible and premium, but do not remove required coverage without checking the contract.
Ask how the deductible is applied
Ask whether you pay the repair shop, whether it is subtracted from a settlement, and what happens if damage is less than the deductible. A deductible does not turn an excluded loss into a covered one. Confirm coverage first, then apply the deductible to eligible damage.
Questions readers ask
Does a higher deductible always lower the price?
It often does for the affected coverage, but the actual saving must come from your insurer's proposal. Small changes sometimes produce little saving.
Does the liability limit have the same deductible?
Not necessarily. A deductible for damage to your own car is separate from liability coverage. Check each coverage rather than applying one number to the entire policy.
Sources and further reading
General educational information. Policy wording, state requirements, and provider decisions control actual coverage. These guides are research-assisted and have not been reviewed by a licensed insurance professional. Examples use hypothetical figures. Report a correction.
Use our worksheet to compare premiums, deductibles, and coverage differences. Your entries stay in this browser tab.
Open the quote comparison worksheet